Started recording in Nashville

The band spent several months recording in Nashville, Tennessee with producer Brendan O’Brien , then resumed touring in April 2010 with the intention of returning to the studio “in the first week of June” to complete the new record. Drummer John Humphrey confirmed in August that recording was completed, and the album was in the mixing process. He said that the band believed this album to be their best work, and that the songs are “very strong, melodic, and heavy at times”. Morgan confirmed the album’s completion in September, and gave the expected release date as early 2011. A new song, “No Resolution”, was debuted on 4 September 2010, during a live show at the DuQuoin, IL State Fair. McLawhorn and Humphrey, in a radio interview, announced that the new album would be titled Holding Onto Strings Better Left to Fray , and that it would be released in May. The album’s first single, ” Country Song “, was released on 8 March in the US and on 4 April in the United Kingdom, and the new album was released on 17 May 2011. Seether reached their highest position on the US Billboard 200 Charts when Holding Onto Strings Better Left to Fray rose to the Number 2 position. It also reached number one on the US Rock Albums , US Alternative Albums , and US Hard Rock Album Charts. Their single-week sales of 61,000 records was their best since Karma and Effect sold 82,000 copies in 2005. Billboard named Seether the No. 1 Active and No. 1 Heritage Rock Artist of 2011. A remix EP of the Holding Onto Strings Better Left to Fray album, titled Remix EP , was released on 7 February 2012.