Critical response mixed

Public reaction to the band’s music has been mixed, particularly on social media platforms like Twitter , “perhaps the last public space for unfettered music criticism in an increasingly anti-critical landscape”, according to Vice magazine’s Larry Fitzmaurice in 2016. In an essay on the critical response, he said they have been “the Most Hated and Loved Band in the World” and described “as underrated and overhyped, although the needle has far more often swung towards the former direction”. Veteran rock critic Robert Christgau said he thinks “they suck” and should not be called a “rock band” as they do not “rock”. In Fitzmaurice’s opinion, the band’s debut album was mainly a straightforward rock album recorded “with a soft-focus and especially British sensibility”, while I Like It When You Sleep was only rock music in the loosest sense of the word. Overall, he said their music is pop “in the realm of Alternative”, most comparable to INXS .